Fred Did Fine

Watched the Republican debate on CNBC. Fred Thompson did fine. It was obvious it was his first debate but he handled the issues well. His speaking style is different of course, deliberate and resonant. I think it's good he was specific on Social Security, in contrast to the other candidates. He got off a base-pleasing quip at Chris Matthews when Matthews stepped out of the moderator role and expressed disapproval of an answer--Fred said "that's your opinion Chris".

Romney made a point to speak to Michigan, and emphasized his health care plan over Hillary's. Giuliani was in good, energetic form, going after Hillary on her indecision on Iran and her expensive and punitive plans for America. McCain was his usual crusty self. I don't agree with him on global warming, but he got in a good plug for clean nuclear, and of course he was strong on the war on terror.

UPDATE: WaPo analysis: "Thompson stays on script", but undercut their point, as he got in more than one effective off the cuff remark:

A late entry to the race, Thompson good-naturedly handled the ribbing he took for waiting until now to participate in debates.

"This is a lot like 'Law & Order,' senator. It has a huge cast, the series seems to go on forever, and Fred Thompson shows up at the end," Romney quipped to laughter.

Thompson nodded and smiled _ then shot back slyly: "Not bad, not bad. And to think I thought I was going to be the best actor on the stage!"

Fred Barnes gives a fellow Fred thumbs up, "Thompson Passed the Test". Byron York, NRO, RCP: No Doubt Thompson is in the First Tier.

UPDATE: With most top Democrats (Hillary remains on the ballot) pulling out of Michigan, an open primary state, turnout may be depressed, or shift to the Republicans. This presumably helps Giuliani or McCain and hurts Romney, who otherwise would be favored with local ties. Detroit Free Press:

With the GOP field debating Tuesday in Dearborn, state party Chairman Saul Anuzis said the candidates are "more than happy to take advantage" of the Democrats' absence.

Some political observers expressed concern that an incomplete field of Democrats could send voters to the Republican primary, where they could skew that party's results.

In February 2000, many Democrats voted in the Republican open primary and helped John McCain score an upset victory over George W. Bush.